Tyre Buying Guide: Performance vs Comfort Choices Explained

Extreme Performance Tyre? High performance tyre? Touring tyre? Comfort tyre?

When it comes to purchasing tyre, its not just about the types of tyres (summer, all season, all weather), but also the category which determines the tyre performance. Tyre performance affects driving experience, and your driving habit decide which one suit you the most. Not the technician or salesperson who uses various reasons to convince you to buy tyres that they want you to install.

I also came across several customers who wanted to get Pilot Sport 4 (ultra high performance) but its out of stock. they look for Primacy 4 (touring comfort) instead of looking for the same category substitute such as Goodyear F1 Asymmetric 6 (F1A6) and Bridgestone Potenza Sport.

The result? Some drivers complaint about the performance not meeting up their expectations. Then they complaint about the brand rather than the tyre model.

This article will list out different categories of tyre models to assist your decision to install your desired tyres. I classify them into three main categories – extreme performance, (ultra) high performance and touring comfort models.

(Ultra) High Performance Tyre

High Performance Tyre category can be separated into (in order of traction level):

Max performance > Ultra Ultra High Performance (UUHP) > Ultra High Performance (UHP) > High Performance

To make it simple, it is easier to see these tyres as high performance category. These tyres give you high control steering, stick on the road better than touring comfort models.

Pros:

  • High traction
  • High control
  • Short braking distance

Cons:

  • High wearoff (easily worn off)
  • Noiser than touring tyres
  • More fuel(electric) consumption

Examples of high performance tyre:

Michelin Pilot Sport 4 S
(Max Performance)
Michelin Pilot Sport 5
(Ultra high performance)
Continental Sport Contact 7
(Ultra high performance)
Continental MaxContact 7
(Ultra high performance)
Goodyear F1
Asymmetric 6
(Ultra high performance)
Bridgestone Potenza Sport Evo
(Ultra high performance)
Kumho Ecsta Sport S (PS72S)
(Ultra high performance)
Dunlop Sport Maxx 060+
(Ultra high performance)
Toyo Proxes Sport 2
(Ultra high performance)

Suitable for drivers who:

  • Speed, especially during cornering (spirited / performance driving)
  • Wanted a shorter braking distance
  • With absolute high grip as first priority

Touring Tyres

Some brands offer touring tyres with two categories. One for better grip level and the other purely for fuel efficient and comfort. One example of this will be Yokohama Advan dB V553 vs Yokohama BluEarth AE51. Advan dB V553 offers higher grip than AE51.

These types of tyre provide low rolling resistant (fuel saving) and comfort for your journey. An exact opposite of high performance tyre. As the name implies, tour, is for driving for a long distance (and the need for comfort).

Pros:

  • Low noise
  • Low wearoff (higher mileage usage)
  • Low fuel(electric) consumption

Cons:

  • Grip and control not as good as high performance tyre
  • Longer braking distance compared to high performance tyre

Examples of touring comfort tyre:

Michelin Primacy 5Continental PremiumContact 7Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance 2 (EGP2)
Yokohama Advan dB V553Toyo Proxes ComfortDunlop BlueResponse TG
Kumho Ecsta HS52Bridgestone Turanza 6Pirelli Cinturato P7

Suitable for drivers who:

  • Always keep some distance away from other vehicles
  • Comfort and Low noise as first priority

Extreme Performance Tyres

Aka semi-slick tyres. These tyres are legally permitted for street use. They are not completely smooth racing slicks; instead, they retain partial tread patterns to balance water drainage and compliance with road regulations.

Pros:

  • Very high dry traction

Cons:

  • Very high fuel consumption
  • Very high wear off
  • Very noisy

Examples of extreme performance tyre:

Bridgestone RE-71RZToyo R1R / R888RMichelin Cup 2

Conclusion

With more people purchasing new (electric) vehicles, they come across different brands and models that do not fit their driving habit. I have customers who complaint original equipped Michelin e.Primacy slip during rainy days. They have no idea that what they need is high performance tyre rather than a touring comfort tyre.

Whether the tyre is summer or all season and electric vehicle tyre or normal tyre, each of them will fall into one of this category. Knowing the basic of the tyre, finding out whether you need a summer tyre or all season tyre, high performance or touring comfort tyre, and corresponding tread pattern (asymmetric vs symmetric vs directional) will help you to get the most suitable tyre for your vehicle.

AXA Travel, Home, Accidential Insurance offer promotion periodically as well as Zurich general insurance.
To purchase automotive tire, batteries and automobile, travel and personal insurance in HK, whatsapp Jimmy +852 5113 0668

Follow us on Tyrehood facebook page to get the latest automotive and insurance information. 👀 More travel guide is also available for your reference.

Other related articles:

-> Summer tyre vs all season tyre vs all weather tyre
-> Tyre Tread Pattern Explained – Asymmetric vs Symmetric vs Directional
-> Electric Vehicle Tyre vs Normal tyre

Other articles:

-> Tyre related information
-> Automotive Battery related information
-> Vehicle maintenance and DIY
-> Global Travel Guide

Posted In : ,